Loading…

Loading grant details…

Active Development AidData Chinese Aid

Bank of China and other Chinese state-owned commercial banks contribute to $1.251 billion syndicated loan for 510MW Batang Toru Hydropower Plant Construction Project

$1.07M USD

Funder Bank of China (BOC)|Unspecified Chinese State-owned Bank
Recipient Organization PT North Sumatra Hydro Energy (PT NSHE)
Country Indonesia
Start Date Mar 01, 2023
End Date Jun 07, 2030
Duration 2,655 days
Number of Grantees 1
Roles Recipient
Data Source AidData Chinese Aid
Grant ID 111094
Grant Description

China Eximbank leads $1.251 billion syndicated loan for 510MW Batang Toru Hydropower Plant Construction Project in Indonesia 2023 The 510MW Batang Toru Hydropower Plant Construction Project is designed as an Independent Power Project (IPP). Its total expected cost is $1.67 billion and it is being financed according to a debt-to-equity ratio of 75:25.

The dam was initially proposed by NSHE in 2012.

Then, on December 21, 2015, NSHE signed a Power Purchase Agreement (PPA) contract with Perusahaan Listrik Negara (PLN), Indonesia’s state-owned power distribution company.

In September 2017, PT North Sumatra Hydro Energy (NSHE) — a special purpose vehicle — signed a syndicated loan agreement with Bank of China, China Eximbank, China Minsheng Bank, and other lenders for the 510MW Batang Toru Hydropower Plant Construction Project.

The proceeds of the loan were to be used by the borrower to partially finance a $1.035 billion EPC contract between NSHE and Sinohydro, which was signed in November 2015.

The purpose of the project is to install a 510-megawatt (MW) hydroelectric power plant — with four 4x127.5MW generators (Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4) — along the Batang Toru River in South Tapanuli District of North Sumatra Province (exact locational coordinates: 1°34′49.4″N 99°10′07.8″E).

Upon completion, it is expected that the power plant will produce 2,214 GWh annually and meet 15% of the peak load electricity needs of North Sumatra Province. The project’s originally expected completion date is December 31, 2021. Sinohydro is the EPC contractor responsible for implementation. The pre-construction stage of the project began in mid-2016 and construction began around June 2017.

However, by March 2018, the bank syndicate withdrew its support for the project on environmental grounds.

On October 29, 2018, Sinohydro signed an implementation agreement for the operations and maintenance of the overseas power plant.

Then, in August 2019, construction was suspended after some employees of Sinohydro were terminated because they were unable to properly carry out their duties and 125 replacement workers were unable to reach the Batang Toru project site (due to a travel ban).

On June 18, 2020, Muhammad Ikhsan Asaad, who was responsible for overseeing the project for state-owned utility PLN, said the Batang Toru hydropower plant was supposed to begin commercial operations (COD) in August 2022, based on the agreement between PLN and project developer PT North Sumatra Hydro Eenergy (NHSE).

However, the plant's COD was further delayed in 2020 (to 2025) due to the COVID-19 pandemic and environmental concerns.

In November 2021, SDIC Power Holdings Co., Ltd. (SDIC Power) — a Chinese state-owned company — acquired a 69.9975% ownership stake in NSHE. The minority shareholders in NSHE are Pembangkitan Jawa Bali Investment (PJBI) and Asia Hydria Pte. Ltd (Asia Hydria). They hold 25% and 5.0025% ownership stakes in NSHE, respectively.

Then, on November 24, 2022, SDIC Power announced that China Eximbank had agreed to lead the issuance of a $1.251 billion syndicated loan to NSHE for the 510MW Batang Toru Hydropower Plant Construction Project.

In March 2023, a syndicate of banks (led by China Eximbank) signed a loan agreement with NSHE for the 510MW Batang Toru Hydropower Plant Construction Project.

📋 Loan / Grant Terms
💰 Loan Amountreportedly carries an 18-year maturity and an 8-year grace period
📅 Maturity18 years
⏳ Grace Period8 years

China Eximbank's contribution is captured in Record ID#61098. The project’s groundbreaking ceremony took place on January 8, 2022. The construction of access roads to the project site took place during calendar year 2022. By December 2022, the project had achieved a 26% completion rate. The first batch of concrete was poured into the dam on November 17, 2023.

By July 2024, the project had achieved a 62% completion rate. The dam was capped on March 24, 2025 after the last batch of concrete was poured. The project's expected completion date was pushed from December 2021 to December 2026. The Batang Toru Hydropower Plant site is the only known habitat of the Tapanuli orangutan.

Scientists and environmentalists claim that, in addition to impacting 10% of the critically endangered Tapanuli orangutan's already dwindling habitat, infrastructure for the dam (roads and high-voltage power lines) will fragment the orangutan population below viable levels by degrading important wildlife corridors and increase the likelihood of even further development.

The area is also home to other critically endangered animals, including the Sumatran tiger, Sumatran orangutan and Sunda pangolin. Between 70 and 100 square kilometers (27 and 39 square miles) could be cleared for the dam and reservoir.

However, a spokesman for NHSE said that less than 6 square kilometers would be cleared and they would voluntarily abide by international standards for environmental and social impact assessment. Although many indigenous community members have sold their land to NHSE, some are vowing to fight the project.

They have held local demonstrations and even flew to Jakarta to protest in front of the presidential palace. The proposed dam will reportedly affect the livelihoods of some 100,000 people who live downstream.

The project lies near a fault line, and there is a risk of earthquakes, but this was not mentioned in the environmental impact assessment (EIA) for the project. For these and other reasons, the Indonesian environmental group WALHI is planning a lawsuit to halt construction.

On March 4, 2019, Bank of China released a public statement, noting that it 'will evaluate the project very carefully and make prudent decisions by duly considering the promotion of green finance, the fulfillment of social responsibility as well as the adherence to commercial principles.' Three days earlier, on March 1, 2019, activists staged a series of coordinated protests outside BOC branches and Chinese diplomatic missions in cities including Jakarta, New York, Hong Kong, Manila and Johannesburg.

The activists called upon Bank of China to rescind its funding for the Batang Toru hydropower project, saying that allowing it to proceed would devastate the most critical areas of the Batang Toru ecosystem in northern Sumatra and drive the Tapanuli orangutan (Pongo tapanuliensis) to extinction.

📋 Staff Comments
  1. This project is also known as the Batang Toru Hydropower Plant. It is considered to be part of the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). The Chinese project title is 巴丹托鲁水电站 or 以印度尼西亚苏门答腊巴丹多鲁(Batang Toru)水电站项目 or 巴丹托鲁水电站项目 or 巴塘项目.
  2. PT Dharma Hydro Nusantara (PT DHN) is the majority shareholder in NSHE, with a 52.82% ownership stake, and Asia Ecoenergy Development A and B (Singapore) together own 96% of PT DHN. Asia Ecoenergy A and B are subsidiaries of Asia Ecoenergy Development (Hong Kong), which in turn is a subsidiary of Zhefu Holding Group, based in Hangzhou, China. Fareast Green Energy is also an NSHE shareholder, with a 22.18% ownership stake. The remaining NSHE shareholder is PT PJB Investasi (PT PJBI), and PT PJBI, in turn, is owned by PT Perusahaan Listrik Negara (PT PLN). PT PLN is a state-owned company that generates and distributes the majority of Indonesia’s electricity.
  3. One individual connects many of these companies. Shen Decai is director of NSHE, Asia Ecoenergy Development (Hong Kong), Asia Ecoenergy Development (Hong Kong), Asia Ecoenergy Development A and B (Singapore), and PT DHN,13 as well as the vice president of Zhefu Holding Group. In the past, Shen was also the general manager of Sinohydro Resources.
  4. It is known that 7 banks participated in the March 2023 syndicated loan (https://native.kontan.co.id/news/pembiayaan-faktor-kunci-pengembangan-energi-terbarukan) and that the syndicate was organized and led by China Eximbank (https://q.stock.sohu.com/cn,gg,600886,9130336216.shtml). For the time being, AidData assumes that all other participants in the syndicate were PRC state-owned creditors and that all banks contributed equally. The equal contribution for this loan is $178,714,286 (1,251,000,000/7). However, this issue merit further investigation. There is some suggestive evidence that China Guangfa Bank and China Minsheng Bank may have participated in the March 2023 loan agreement (see https://xueqiu.com/1050604042/237008829).
  5. In 2023, Bank of China Group Insurance Company Limited (BOCG Insurance) -- a subsidiary of Bank of China Limited that offers a variety of insurance plans in Hong Kong -- provided insurance coverage for the 510MW Batang Toru Hydropower Plant Construction Project (see https://pic.bankofchina.com/bocappd/report/202403/P020240328720914424945.pdf). The specific nature of the insurance coverage is unknown. This issue warrants further investigation.
📚 Sources & References
  • Bank of China to evaluate Batang Toru hydropower plant project
  • Batang Toru Dam
  • Bank of China’s Notes on the Hydroelectric Dam Project in Batang Toru of Indonesia
  • China-backed Sumatran dam threatens the rarest ape in the world
  • Batang Toru Dam
  • 公司签订印尼巴丹托鲁水电站运行维护合同
  • Coronavirus delays construction progress on 510-MW Batang Toru hydropower plant in Indonesia
  • Dam that threatens orangutan habitat faces three-year delay
  • Indonesian dam raises questions about UN hydropower carbon loophole
  • Covid-19 halts Indonesia's Batang Toru hydropower project
  • The Batang Toru Hydroelectric Power Project is delayed until 2025
  • Final Report Addendum Environmental
  • Social and Health Impact Assessment
  • Batang Toru Hydrodam Progress (Jun 2017 - Aug 2018)
  • Scientists urge Indonesian president to nix dam in orangutan habitat
  • Batang Toru hydropower project
  • Bank of China to review funding of dam in orangutan habitat in Sumatra
  • Death of lawyer fighting Chinese-funded Indonesian dam casts shadow over project
  • 公司印尼巴丹托鲁水电站项目大坝左岸成功实施首次爆破
  • 浙富控股集团股份有限公司、东兴证券股份有限公司 关于浙富控股集团股份有限公司非公开发行股票告知函有关问题的回复
  • 公司签署印尼两个水电站项目EPC合同
  • DAMMING EVIDENCE How the Batang Toru megadam threatens a new orangutan species with extinction
  • 扎根印尼 砥砺前行
  • 巴塘水电站首台机组水轮机转轮完工
  • 印尼巴塘水电站项目举行大坝开挖动土仪式
  • 印尼巴塘水电站最重要运输通道贯通
  • 中国进出口银行印度尼西亚巴塘水电项目聘请技术顾问项目成交公告
  • Construction of Sumatra’s Biggest Hydroelectric Power Plant Tunnel
  • NOTICE OF THE 2021 ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING
  • Chinese state-owned company accused of endangering rare orang-utans
  • James Clayton-Payne
  • SDIC Power Holdings - Notice of the 2022 seventh EGM
  • SDIC Power Holdings Co.
  • Ltd. Annual Report 2021
  • 中国进出口银行印度尼西亚巴塘水电项目聘请技术顾问项目竞争性磋商公告
  • 环球荣获2024年度ALB印尼法律大奖多项提名
  • 国投电 力 印尼 5 1 0 M W 水 电站预计 2 0 2 6 年投产
  • 环球荣膺2024年度IFLR亚太法律大奖多项提名
  • Makarim & Taira S. received the award for Project Finance Deal of the Year from ALB
  • PT North Sumatera Hydro Energy’s US$1.251 billion financing for the development of the 510 MW Batang Toru Hydroelectric Power Plant in Sumatera
  • China
  • 环球荣获 ALM“2024年度亚洲法律大奖”八项提名
  • ALB Indonesia Law Awards 2023: ESG-Advisory Law Firm of the Year
  • M&A Deal of the Year
  • Project Finance Deal of the Year, and Dealmaker of the Year
  • IFLR Asia-Pacific Awards 2024: shortlist revealed
  • China’s big firms put reputation at risk in Batang Toru power plant
  • Concerns over the Batang Toru Dam and its impacts on the Tapanuli orangutan
  • Pembiayaan
  • Faktor Kunci Pengembangan Energi Terbarukan
  • LAPORAN KEUANGAN KONSOLIDASIAN/ CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
  • 国投电力:国投电力控股股份有限公司关于为NSHE公司提供担保的公告, 2023 Annual Report
  • ALB Indonesia Law Awards 2023
  • Bank of China Corporate Social Responsibility Report - Environmental Social Governance
  • BATANG TORU HYDROPOWER PROJECT Factcheck and References on Key Issues
  • Case Study: Batang Toru
  • Indonesia Summary
  • PLN Nusantara Renewables and PT NSHE Distribute six Sarcificial Cows In Marancar District
  • Hydroelectric project in Sumatra risks extinction of world’s rarest orangutan
  • 印尼多举措推动能源转型, 《中国金融》|中国进出口银行副行长王康:发挥银团贷款在高水平对外开放中的重要作用, 《中国金融》|中国进出口银行副行长王康:发挥银团贷款在高水平对外开放中的重要作用
  • 印尼巴塘水电站大坝全线封顶 Loan applications and disbursements are still being received and processed as the projects continue to evolve. Ongoing monitoring and evaluation are in place to ensure project continuity.
All Grantees

PT North Sumatra Hydro Energy (PT NSHE)

Advertisement
Apply for grants with GrantFunds
Advertisement
Browse Grants on GrantFunds
Interested in applying for this grant?

Complete our application form to express your interest and we'll guide you through the process.

Apply for This Grant